This power is separate and apart from the common law doctrine of plain view seizure. Does a similar doctrine apply to the sense of touch. Should the court ever have created the plain view doctrine. Second, not only must the officer be lawfully located in a place from which the object can be plainly seen, but he or she must also have a lawful. However, under exigent circumstances a plain view seizure will be valid even though you are on private property or invading an area where someone has a reasonable expectation of privacy. Plain view doctrine legal definition of plain view doctrine. Circuit court ruled that dreamhost had to comply with the search warrant, the arguments that dreamhost raised reflect some uncertainty. Canadian criminal procedure and practicesearch and.
Sage video bringing teaching, learning and research to life. Plain view doctrine guidelines blue book you must observe the item from a place where you have a lawful right to be. Aug 30th, 2017 christopher folk current affairs, fourth amendment, search and seizure. The plain view doctrine requires probable cause to be established prior to the search or seizure of a piece of evidence. This court has acknowledged this exception to a warrantless seizure and stated, in reference to the level of sus picion r equi red to s ear ch, that since t he d icke rson p lain feel exception for the discovery of contraband during a patdown search for weapons is the. Fourth amendmentrequiring probable cause for searches. The state argues that the plain touch corollary to the plain view doctrine justified zarses reaching into the defendants pocket and pulling out the baggie. However, articles exposed to the plain view of others are subject to a warrantless seizure on probable cause, for no search is involved and. Cq press your definitive resource for politics, policy and people.
Sage books the ultimate social sciences digital library. According to the encyclopedia of the american constitution, about its article titled 606 plain view doctrinethe fourth amendment protects persons and their effects against unreasonable searches and seizures. An overview of the plain view doctrine, one of the main elements of the fourth amendment. If, however, the police lack probable cause to believe that an object in plain view is contraband without conducting some further search of the objecti. In the united states, the plain view doctrine is an exception to the fourth amendments warrant requirement that allows an officer to seize evidence and contraband that are found in plain view during a lawful observation. Sage reference the complete guide for your research journey. For the plain view doctrine to apply for discoveries, the three. The original standard was that the officer had to be lawfully present, meaning they had a right to be where they were when they s. The court in long justified this latter holding by reference to our cases under the plain view doctrine. Inadvertence the second requirement for a valid plain view seizure is that the dis. The fourth amendment contains an exception for plain view.
The plain view doctrine allows law enforcement officers to collect evidence or contraband found in plain view while they are lawfully present. Sage business cases real world cases at your fingertips. In the context of searches and seizures, the principle that provides that objects perceptible by an officer who is rightfully in a position to observe them can be seized without a search warrant and are admissible as evidence the u. Under the plain view rule, it was also lawful for the officers to inspect anything in plain view, including the two opaque vials in the map pocket of the driverside door. One of these exceptions is the doctrine of plain view. The plain view doctrine, the text messages and the folder. The doctrine is based on the united states supreme court decision horton v. Appeals court clarifies scope of plain view doctrine in.
Under that doctrine, ifpolice are lawfully in a position from which they view an object, if its. In the united states, the plain view doctrine allows an officer to seize any evidence the find that is in plain view. The fourth amendment, for example, does not apply to searches and seizures conducted by private citizens or organizations, nor does it apply to informationgathering. Although law enforcement had a warrant to search the house, officers seized items not listed in the warrant during its execution. Under the plain view doctrine, if police are lawfully in a position from which they view an object, if its incriminating character is immediately apparent, and if the officers have a lawful right of access to the object, they may seize it without a warrant. The plain view doctrine is an exception to the fourth amendment rights allowing law enforcement agents to make observations in a public place and the police see an object in plain view that was used in a crime the police can them seize that item.
The plain view doctrine holds that an official may lawfully note all evidence within plain view if the official has a legal right to be in the location from which the observations are made m. Covering the key concepts, events, laws and legal doctrines, court decisions, and litigators and litigants, this new reference on the law of search and seizurein the physical as well as the online worldprovides a unique overview for individuals seeking to understand the fourth amendment to the u. The plain view doctrine is an exception to the warrant requirement of the fourth amendment. Plain view doctrine simple english wikipedia, the free. The inadvertency requirement of the plain view doctrine in north carolina the plain view doctrine holds generally that if, while lawfully engaged in an activity in a particular place, police officers perceive a suspicious object, they may seize it immediately, without a search warrant. Plain view doctrine definition, examples, cases, processes. In this lesson, you will learn about the basics of the plain view doctrine and how the doctrine is. The doctrine is also regularly used by tsa officers while screening persons and property at u. The police cant just share the contents of a seized iphone with other agencies, court rules.
Evidence in a container can not possibly be identified by plain. Plain view refers to the sense of sight, which is the most common way probable cause is established. Fourth amendment plain view doctrine en banc ninth. The plain view doctrine refers to the concept that so long as criminal evidence or contraband is left out in plain view, officers conducting a. This post peers into a small facet of the states initial investigation into the murder of odin lloyd. Introduction the fourth amendment to the united states constitution protects individuals against. Once the mistake is discovered, the government cannot use the authority of the warrant, or of the wiretap order, to conduct a search or. The article discusses web service provider dream hosts issues within the scope of search warrants related to data. The plain view doctrine is an exception to the warrant requirement that allows an officer to seize items that she observes from a lawful vantage point, to which she has a lawful right of access, and which are immediately apparent as contraband or evidence of a crime. But the plain view doctrine did not give bartol the authority to open the vials, the court concluded. Thus, the seizure of the evidence from the trunk of the car can be sustained under the plain view doctrine only if the search for the gun was itself constitutional. Reliance on the plain view doctrine in this case is therefore misplaced, since the antecedent search cannot be sustained. The incriminating character of the object should be immediately identifiable. Under the doctrine, police may seize evidence without a warrant when they observe incriminating evidence in plain view.
Is this doctrine difficult for police officers to keep in mind in their daily work. The plain view doctrine allows a police officer to seize objects not described in a warrant when executing a lawful search or seizure if he observes the object in plain view and has probable cause to believe that it is connected with criminal activities. Although the ninth circuits rules provide some guidance in a murky area, we are inclined to find more common ground with the dissents position that jettisoning the plain view doctrine entirely in digital evidence cases is an efficient but overbroad approach. We disagree and affirm the trial courts suppression order. This guide will explain how the plain view doctrine works in terms of the fourth amendment laws.
Analysis the police cant just share the contents of a. It is an exception to items spelled out in a search warrant and to the fourth amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. A recent article in legaltech news highlights the difficulty in applying the plain view doctrine within the digital realm. Seized objects must be immediately apparent as evidence or contraband. Plain view doctrine if police are lawfully in a position from which they view an object, if its incriminating character is apparent e. Constitution safeguards against unreasonable searches and seizures, but is not implicated in all searches and seizures. The doctrine that holds that any evidence or contraband that is out in plain sight may be seized by a police officer during an observation and without a warrant. Police can seize anything in their plain view, regardless of whether their presence in an area is justifiable. There are, however, exceptions to warrantless searches and one of the most major exceptions is the plain view doctrine. The plain view doctrine loses its inadvertency under the fourth amendment1 of the united states constitu tion, police must conduct searches and seizures pursuant to search warrants which specifically describe the place to be searched and. The fourth amendment protects equally against unreasonable searches and seizures.
Fourth amendmentrequiring probable cause for searches and seizures under the plain view doctrine arizona v. For the plain view doctrine, to what lengths can a police. The plain view doctrine is an exception to the fourth amendment rights allowing law enforcement agents to make observations in a public place and the police see an object in plain view that was used in a crime the police can them seize that item under the plain view doctrine law. Study 39 terms criminal procedure terminology flashcards. In terms of police searches, what constitutes plain view. Generally, under the 4 th amendment, police officers are required to obtain a warrant or identify an accepted exception to the 4 th amendment in order to conduct searches and seizures of individuals. Rothstein, occupational safety and health law, section230, p. The plain view doctrine allows police or law enforcement to seize evidence if the property or item provides the officer with probable cause because it is either contraband guns, drugs, drug paraphernalia or is thought to.
Supreme court has developed and refined the plain view doctrine over time. The doctrine of plain view is fairly simply to understand. Emily arochi plain view open fields adj275 february 7, 2010 in our readings the plain view doctrine states that items that are within the sight of an officer who is legally in a place from which the view is made may properly be seized without a warrantas long as such items are immediately recognizable as subject to seizure. Plain view and plain touch compared as discussed in chapter 3, probable cause is usually established through the use of the officers five sensessight, touch, smell, hearing, and taste.
779 1028 1100 1057 677 1202 1066 474 452 261 964 1168 852 344 181 820 1115 338 105 1588 1457 658 922 377 548 1044 813 716 1140 598 338 209 260 151 838